Season to Taste

Nicky Pellegrino writes:


As you're reading this, stop for a moment and think about what you can smell right now. Toast browning perhaps. Coffee brewing. Fresh cut grass as a neighbour mows the lawn. Now imagine not being able to smell anything at all.

Our olfactory ability is probably the sense we most take for granted and yet, as Molly Birnbaum discovered when she lost hers, living without it can be devastating.

Season To Taste (Portobello, $36.99) is US writer Birnbaum’s story of what happened when a head injury robbed her of the ability to smell anything at all. At that point she was 22 and an aspiring chef about to take up her place at the Culinary Institute of America. Being hit by a car while out jogging changed everything because when her sense of smell went so did her ability to taste beyond the basics of sweet, sour and salty. Cooking had been her raison d’etre and with a career as a chef now beyond her she had to rethink her whole life.

What Birnbaum did instead was try to find out everything she could about the inner workings of the nose – how we smell, why we smell and what it means for us. Relentlessly curious, she meets other sufferers of anosmia (the clinical term for the lack of ability to perceive smells), talks to doctors, scientists and perfumers, and begins to understand the breadth of her loss. She can’t smell danger, a lover’s skin or any of the scents that link her to her past. Even the memory of smell eludes her.

“The absence of smell for me was a vicious monotone thing,” she tells us. “I began to see how for others, too, it could leave depression and anxiety, disordered eating, and a lack of sexual desire. Something much deeper than the thick salt-fat scent of a chicken roasting in the kitchen is lost without the ability to smell.”

But when Birnbaum attempts to cook again there’s a faint whiff of something. It smells of the woods and earth, is pungent and warm. It’s rosemary.

She embarks on a mission to regain her sense of smell. It happens very slowly and is weird at times – at one point she thinks she can smell her own brain. But with extraordinary tenacity she follows every lead in the hope of a cure: visiting a pioneering flavour laboratory, meeting writer and neurologist Oliver Sacks, even enrolling at a perfume school in Grasse, France which seems extreme but it’s there that Birnbaum realises it’s possible to train herself to smell again.

Is she cured by the end? Who knows. This is one of the more mysterious areas of science and, while she can smell almost everything today, what Birnbaum doesn’t know is if they smell exactly the same way to her now as they used to.

Her olfactory exploration makes for fascinating reading. While she comes across as a fairly intense person, she’s a smart, interesting, often quite journalistic writer who manages to pack a lot of science into Season To Taste while still keeping things lively.

The result is part food memoir, part love story but mostly this is the record of a young woman battling adversity and trying to find her way in life. I found it inspirational, honest and engrossing.

Season To Taste a book to get you thinking – and smelling – more.

Footnote:
Nicky Pellegrino is a succcesful Auckland-based author of popular fiction, The Italian Wedding was published in May 2009, Recipe for Life was published in April, 2010, while her latestThe Villa Girls, was published in April this year.

She is also the Books Editor of the Herald on Sunday where the above review was first published on 4 September, 2011