Tuesday, July 09, 2013

Poem of the week: An Essay on Criticism by Alexander Pope

Whilst counselling restraint, Pope's famously stinging wit is here trained on targets that can still be seen today

Alexander Pope
Looking back to classical examples ... detail from portrait of Alexander Pope. Photograph: Bettmann/Corbis

This week's choice is an extract from Part Three of Alexander Pope's An Essay on Criticism. The whole poem runs to 744 lines, but that shouldn't put you off! It's as readable as it was 400 years ago, and highly pertinent to many burning literary issues – writers' prizes and who judges them, for instance. Pope wrote it in 1709, the year his first work, four pastorals, appeared in print. He was barely 21. When it was published in 1711 it earned the young poet immediate acclaim.


Typically, Pope undertook the work in a competitive spirit. He was an ambitious, driven writer, largely self- and home-educated because of a painful spinal deformation, and because the repressive legislation against Catholics at the time denied him access to a university.


It was Nicholas Boileau's treatise, L'Art Poétique, which fired Pope to produce his own study of literary-critical principles. Like Boileau, he champions neoclassicism and its governing aesthetic of nature as the proper model for art. His pantheon of classical writers, the "happy few," as he calls them, includes Quintilian, Longinus and, most importantly, Horace.


Pope's ideals may be recycled, but there's no doubting his passionate belief in them. Deployed in his sparkling heroic couplets, the arguments and summaries are alive with wit, verbal agility and good sense. From his neoclassical scaffolding, he looks outwards to the literary marketplace of his own age. It was a noisy time, and sometimes the reader seems to hear the buzz of the coffee house, the banter, gossip and argument of the writers and booksellers, the jangle of carts and carriages.
More

2 comments:

TK Roxborogh said...

perhaps those who are spewing forth hysterical vitriol about what they've heard about Ted's book Into the River, should read this extract. Pope, himself not shy to be a bit stinging in his comments, speaks wisdom to these NZers who are ranting and chanting such scary stuff (scary because some of them have children and the kids take note and scary because behaviour like that was seen in Nazi Germany and during the fight for Black civil rights in America). Yup, Alexander Pope for parliament.

Beattie's Book Blog said...

Well put TK Roxborogh